Home Body and Fitness Yoga and Pilates: Which Offers More Benefits?

Yoga and Pilates: Which Offers More Benefits?

by Darren Salzar

You go online to look at the classes that are available at your nearby gym because you want to try a new workout. Yoga and Pilates both sound interesting. They both guarantee increased flexibility and strength, and they both feature pictures of contented, fit people striking poses on mats.

But how do yoga and Pilates differ from one another?

While both yoga and Pilates exercise have a wealth of physical and mental advantages, there are some key distinctions between them in terms of their origins, how they affect your body and mind, and what to expect from a typical class.

You can select the practice that best satisfies your fitness and life goals by contrasting yoga and Pilates.

Yoga and Pilates Benefits

History vs. Modern Technology

While both yoga and Pilates focus on executing specific poses while exercising to increase strength and flexibility, the two practices have different historical roots. Yoga and Pilates classes typically have different focuses because of the distinct historical contexts in which they each developed.

 

Yoga

People have been practicing yoga for thousands of years, just like they have been running and wrestling. India is the country where yoga first appeared, and there, over the years, people have practiced and taught it in various ways.

Due to the publication of Swami Vivekananda’s book Raja Yoga in 1986 and his appearance at the 1893 Chicago Parliament of World Religions, modern yoga was first practiced about 150 years ago. In order to make classical Hindu yoga more appealing to Americans and Indians who had been exposed to Western culture and religion, Vivekananda repackaged it.

Modern yoga has grown in acceptance since that time and is now practiced all over the world.

Yoga promotes the following through a series of poses and a deep, mindful breathing technique:

  • Muscle Strength
  • Flexibility
  • Mental discipline
  • Inner peace

Some yoga classes can seem highly tailored for a westernized, results-driven society; for instance, you might find a yoga workshop based on a “office chair” given at a workplace to help staff members cope with stress.

In other ways, the origins of yoga are more obvious. You might hear a yoga instructor refer to a pose in a class by either its Sanskrit or English name.

Yoga exercise classes can concentrate more on breath and mindfulness than a typical Western exercise class because of its history as a spiritual discipline and meditative practice.

 

Pilates

Yoga has a long history, but Pilates workout was only developed recently.

In order to aid in rehabilitation, physical trainer Joseph Pilates developed the technique in the 1920s. Soldiers returning from battle and renowned dancers like Martha Graham and George Balanchine were among the first Pilates students. Both teams wanted to relieve pain and recover from injuries.

Pilates designed his workout regimen to:

  • Increased adaptability
  • Strengthen up
  • Enhance body awareness

Pilates is a form of resistance training, much like weightlifting. Your Pilates instructor will lead you through a series of movements while urging you to pay attention to your core muscles, your breathing, your muscle contractions, and the alignment of your spine. More important than how many times you perform a movement is that it be done fully and correctly.

Some movements use equipment that has been specifically created. Other floorwork-based exercises can be done using nothing more than your body and a mat. If a gym lacks machine access, they can still offer mat Pilates classes.

Pilates movements can be easily changed by instructors to accommodate your physical limitations, in part due to its history as a rehabilitation tool. If you have an injury or another physical condition that your instructor should be aware of, always let them know.

 

Yoga and Pilates: Physical Benefits

In general, yoga and Pilates both offer physical advantages. Both can improve flexibility and strength. However, how those advantages materialize can vary.

Yoga vs Pilates Quotes

Yoga

Numerous studies have looked into the potential health advantages of yoga.

These consist of:

  • Reduced back pain – For some individuals, weekly yoga sessions can alleviate the signs and symptoms of low back pain just as effectively as frequent, arduous stretching exercises.
  • increased bone density– According to one study, yoga practitioners’ spines and hips have more bone density.
  • Enhanced balance– Another study discovered that ten weeks of yoga improved the balance of the study’s athletes.

You can discuss whether or not yoga can help you reach your health goals with your doctor and a yoga instructor if there is a specific health benefit you are hoping to achieve.

 

Pilates

Numerous health advantages for Pilates practitioners have also been reported in studies.

These could result in rises in:

  • Stability
  • Core strength
  • Ultimate strength
  • Flexibility

Importantly, because Pilates has less impact on your joints, it can also work well for people who are recovering from an injury. Pilates offers countless customization options, making it a practical exercise choice for injury rehabilitation when performed in a one-on-one setting with a qualified instructor. For instance, a study found that people who practice Pilates experience less back pain.

Yoga and Pilates both have the potential to give you positive physical results.

 

Yoga and Pilates: Mental Benefits

Yoga and Pilates may have advantages for mental health, even though exercise classes typically focus on physical benefits.

 

Yoga

The benefits of yoga for mental health are well established.

Potential advantages include:

  • Improved visuospatial memory – Study subjects who practiced yoga and meditation had an improvement in their visuospatial memory, which aids in balance, depth perception, and our capacity to both recognize objects and move about the world.
  • Reduced stress – According to one study, yoga helped women lessen their emotional distress as well as the psychological and physical signs of stress.
  • Reduced signs of anxiety and depression – Yoga was also found by researchers to help a group of coal miners with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease reduce their levels of anxiety and depression.

Yoga can be an accessible starting point for those seeking a serene, non-competitive exercise environment.

 

Pilates

Studies indicate that any regular exercise can have a positive impact on your mental health, even though the specific benefits of Pilates for your mental health have not been as thoroughly researched as those of yoga.

Several studies indicate that engaging in regular exercise can enhance your mental health by:

  • Lowering Anxiety
  • Depression Reduction
  • Reduce Negative Emotions
  • Increasing Self-esteem
  • Enhancing Cognitive Function
  • Promoting Social Participation

Pilates can help you improve your physical and mental health if you do it on a regular basis.

You may also like

Leave a Comment